This year Local 1000 of the American Federation of Musicians will be a featured partner at the Great Labor Arts Exchange (GLAE), June 21-24 at the Tommy Douglas Center in Silver Spring, MD. For forty years the Arts Exchange has brought together labor musicians, artists and activists to share their experiences and to inspire each other. As the following article relates, the annual gathering was instrumental in bringing together the original founders of the local.
This year we are happy to present one of our annual Joe Hill Awards to John McCutcheon, one of those founders and a former president of Local 1000.
John McCutcheon, former president of AFM Local 1000
Here is a reprint of an article from Labor Notes on the 20th anniversary.
How Traveling Musicians Won a Union of Their Own
This year marks the 20th birthday of Local 1000, the North American Traveling Musicians Union—the only non-geographic local in the American Federation of Musicians. It took nine years of fierce struggle to form a local that would work for folk musicians and grant us the benefits the AFM can offer.
Troubadours who travel the country, working mostly one-night stands, were falling between the cracks of other musicians locals. We needed one with no geographic restrictions and we wanted protection, a pension, and the right to stand with like-minded people.
The idea for Local 1000 started with a handful of musicians who were coming every year to the Great Labor Arts Exchange, an annual gathering of labor activists, artists, and musicians—people who often are the heart and soul of picket lines and union rallies.
John McCutcheon, an award-winning singer-songwriter and AFM member, recalls a lunch discussion about union war stories. The musicians were amazed at the sacrifices that people in union jobs were willing to make by going on strike, walking away from their jobs, and slugging out the hard stuff.
“Wouldn’t it be amazing if we felt about our union the way these people feel about their unions?” asked musical storyteller and political satirist Charlie King. The question hung in the air until someone said, “Well, why don’t we do something about it!”
The New Deal Committee
Everyone at the Arts Exchange was singing union songs. It was a gathering based on labor, but not everyone was even in the musician’s union. One year, King remembers, the icebreaker was to write on a card your name and what union you belonged to. If you weren’t a member, you had to write “SHAME.”
The discussion of nonunion musicians kept coming up until John O’Connor, who was on the board of AFM Local 76-493 in Seattle when he first came to the Arts Exchange in 1984, invited all the musicians to meet after the day’s activities to find out why people were—or weren’t—in the union.
The excuse at the time was that the AFM was really an old-school union that didn’t represent all musicians. It was meant mostly for symphony musicians, jazz players, people who worked in one city. It wasn’t geared for traveling folksingers who play different cities every night.
As an AFM member in the folk world, you were required to do the tedious work of filing your contract with—and paying dues to—the geographical local where you played. Therefore, every city where you played, you had to find the local, find out the dues for a single engagement, and pay those dues to that local. Yet union officials were very clear there would be no contract enforcement or job protection in return.
Out of this conversation came a half-baked idea to form a rank-and-file movement of traveling performers to make the union relevant to folkies—and make folkies relevant to the union. So the New Deal Committee was formed, an association to represent the specific needs of musicians on the road.
Members paid $35 annual dues to the committee, and also had to be members of the geographic locals where they lived. New Deal would recruit people to join the AFM and at the same time get the union to start doing things that were relevant to us. The steering committee started to organize other troubadours they met on their journeys, and they kept meeting each year at the Arts Exchange to report on progress.
A Pension for Folk Singers
For Charlie King, the focus of starting a local was to earn a pension. At the time, wherever a musician played, the only way to get a pension contribution was to file your contract with that local. The employer made a pension contribution based on the union’s recommended minimum pay rate, called the “scale”—not on the rate you actually charged for your performance. The scales were so low, and the pension contribution was so insignificant, that it would be a very small pension when you got vested. There was no real incentive to participate.
King pointed out that folk musicians charged more than the scales in most locals, which were often well below $100 in those days. He wanted to make the pension contribution fit what we were making. “You know, it would be great if we could start our own local,” he said.
To the credit of the AFM, the union flew the New Deal committee to New York several times for meetings. The AFM felt the pension idea was worth pursuing. The union had been losing members for decades, so its leaders were interested in finding new ways to recruit people—and now here was a committee organizing on its own and showing up on the union’s doorstep.
There was no such thing as a one-night stand in the officers’ world. The AFM didn’t even have a contract for less than three dates. When McCutcheon described a week in the life of a folk musician to AFM’s international secretary and other staffers, they looked at him and said, “You can make a living doing that?” “Not only can we make a living doing this,” McCutcheon said, “but there are hundreds and maybe thousands of people doing it.”
Then in 1987, Marty Emerson, the incoming president of the AFM, and Victor Fuentealba, the outgoing president, both came to the Arts Exchange to speak. Folkie Anne Feeney spoke up and asked, “President Emerson, when are you going to give people like us our own local?” Emerson said, “Well, that’s an interesting idea. We should look into that.”
Making It Official
To get our own local, we needed to write a bylaw that would fit us into the fold. King and O’Connor went to the 1991 AFM convention as guests and introduced the bylaw amendment. It was highly unusual for non-delegates to have the opportunity to address the convention. And they also brought flyers and talked to people about what they were trying to do.
The amendment was referred to the executive board, which decided to approve the charter. But first we had to have our own bylaws and 50 members.
A hundred people had signed the petition to start our own local but they weren’t necessarily members. So a major campaign was launched at the Arts Exchange. When the new local was still short seven members, McCutcheon signed up to do a song in one of the open mic sessions. Instead of singing, he said, “We have a unique opportunity to create this local, but we need seven more people. All you have to do is pay one quarter’s dues to the local. Twenty-five dollars and you can be a part of history!”
And they did. We got the people, and in 1993 we got our charter.
Twenty Years and Counting
It wasn’t all easy after that. We struggled to keep members. But through years of hard work, today we stand 500 members strong, the largest AFM local without a major collective bargaining agreement, and we continue to grow.
We offer contract protection, pension, health insurance, disability insurance, an emergency relief fund for members who fall on hard times, a Fair Trade Music campaign, solidarity, and the knowledge that we are doing the right thing.
Here’s to the next 20 years! Solidarity Forever!
Tret Fure is president of AFM Local 1000 and tours internationally as a singer-songwriter/musician. Read and hear more about her at www.tretfure.com.